Click Here to Go to the Ashbrook Center's Homepage

Subscribe to Our Email Update
 
SEARCH
 

Home



Support the Ashbrook Center



Subscribe to Our E-Mail Update




No Left Turns:
The Ashbrook
Center Blog







Ashbrook Scholar Program

Master of American History and Government






  Podcasts



Other Ashbrook
Web Sites:


AshbrookScholar.org



mahg.ashland.edu



TeachingAmerican
History.org


Document Library

Constitutional Convention

The American Founding



Presidential
Academy.org




Congressional
Academy.org




Letters from
an Ohio Farmer




VindicatingThe
Founders.com




ClassicsOf
Strategy.com

It’s Not Over Until It’s Over:
Why We’re Still in Afghanistan

Editorial
March 2002

by: Mackubin T. Owens


The heavy fighting that erupted in Afghanistan over the weekend is a reminder that a great deal remains to be done in that country, even as we begin to move against al Qaeda in other places. It also indicates a course correction in the U.S. approach that led to problems earlier this year around Tora Bora.

The "Afghan Model," the employment of heavy and accurate air power in conjunction with allied fighters, supported by a small number of U.S. special-operations forces (SOF) to plan and coordinate air strikes, has been touted by some as the wave of the future for the American military. The model seemed to work well earlier in the war as the Taliban collapsed and city after city fell to America’s Afghan allies. It seemed to work again as the al Qaeda base area around Tora Bora was pulverized by massive air strikes.

But even as the campaign in Afghanistan moved from one apparent success to another, dissenters raised some troubling questions. The British press reported that unnamed sources within the Special Air Service (SAS), Britain’s elite SOF, argued that the U.S. approach allowed Osama bin Laden and his ranking al Qaeda lieutenants to escape.

They claimed that the allies had reliable intelligence regarding the location of Osama bin Laden, and that he could have been killed or captured in a raid by the SAS or U.S. SOF, but that the U.S. decision to rely almost exclusively on anti-Taliban Afghans to carry the bulk of the ground combat gave the al Qaeda leadership time to slip away. On the one hand, the anti-Taliban fighters did not place the same priority on capturing or killing the al Qaeda leaders. On the other, press reports indicate that Osama bin Laden and his lieutenants had vast amounts of cash available to bribe local warlords and tribesmen, enabling them to make good their escape when the time came. Critics also took the U.S. to task for not adequately sealing the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Hindsight is always 20/20, but the current round of fighting indicates that the U.S. has modified its approach to the war. It appears that U.S. ground troops are more directly involved in the fighting and that they are taking the lead in sealing off al Qaeda escape routes into Pakistan. The risk associated with this change is already apparent—the likelihood of heavier U.S. casualties.

But we don’t have any choice. Ultimate success in Afghanistan will require ground troops beyond SOF and more direct employment of those ground forces in combat. U.S. air power will continue to be the cornerstone of the war effort, but it is more effective when used in conjunction with ground forces. To use a Zen analogy, air power and ground forces are like the blades of a pair of scissors. Both blades are necessary for cutting.

The intensity of the fighting indicates that the modified approach is working. At Tora Bora, the enemy was able to slip away to fight another day. This time it appears that their escape routes have been cut off. Having been fixed by the ground effort, they now present a lucrative target for massive, concentrated air strikes.

We have entered into is a more dangerous phase of the war and it is entirely possible that there will be more U.S. casualties. Whether it will be the last phase of the war remains to be seen, but it is a necessary one on the road to final success.

Mackubin Thomas Owens is professor of strategy and force planning at the Naval War College in Newport, RI, and an adjunct fellow of the Ashbrook Center. The views expressed here are his own and do not reflect the position of the War College, Navy Department, or Department of Defense.



 


Printer-Friendly Version

Upcoming Events

Mike Huckabee
Thursday, June 28

Maureen O’Connor on the Constitution
Monday, Sept. 17


Recent Publications


A Policy Analysis of Local New York Laws Banning Oil and Gas Exploration by Robert Alt

Obamacare and the Supreme Court: An Opportunity for Reflection by Michael Schwarz

Moratoria on Drilling are Legally Dubious by Robert Alt

Rick Santorum and Limited Government by Andrew E. Busch

Who Owns the Bard? by Ellen Tucker

Clarence Thomas and the Wisdom of the Founding by Ken Masugi

U.S. Headed in the Right Direction by Peter W. Schramm

Deficits and Cultural Politics by David Marion

America’s Future in New Europe by Justin Paulette

Our Discussion of Islam by David Foster

The Tea Party and Nullification by Michael Sabo

Drama Queens: Elizabeth Taylor, Camille Paglia, and the Purposes of Female Power by Julie Ponzi

Honoring Ronald Reagan by Peter W. Schramm

Realigning American Politics: Do We Still Hold These Truths? by Matthew Spalding

Reagan’s Inherent Goodness Made Him One of the Great Presidents by Peter W. Schramm

Reagan the Radical by Stephen Knott


Audio Archive


Terrence Moore on Education Reform (2012)

Stephen Moore on Capitalism (2012)

David Tucker on Fear and Freedom (2012)

Reed Browning on the War of Austrian Succession (2012)

Pat Tiberi on the American Dream (2012)

Ramesh Ponnuru on Obamanomics (2011)

Gordon Lloyd on Political Economy (2011)

Steven Hayward on the Health of Capitalism in America (2011)

John Boehner (2011)

Jonah Goldberg on Liberalism (2010)

Mitt Romney (2010)

John Kasich on the Future of Ohio (2009)

Conference on the Presidency and the Courts featuring President George W. Bush (2008)

Jeb Bush on America’s Promise (2008)

Glenn Beck on Militant Islam (2006)

Karl Rove on Conservatism (2005)

James McPherson on the Battle of Antietam (2005)

David Hackett Fischer on Liberty and Freedom (2004)

William Bennett on the Politics of War (2004)

Edwin Meese on Homeland Security (2003)

Barbara Bush on CSPAN (2003)

Victor Davis Hanson on Terrorism (2003)

Benjamin Netanyahu on Attaining Peace (2002)

Clarence Thomas on the Supreme Court (1999)

Margaret Thatcher on Ronald Reagan and Freedom (1993)

Dick Cheney on American Foreign Policy (1991)

Ronald Reagan on John Ashbrook (1983)

  Real Logo
Visit our archive of over 200 other Ashbrook speeches at
audio.ashbrook.org or subscribe to our
Events Podcast.








ASHBROOK SCHOLAR PROGRAM | MASTER OF AMERICAN HISTORY AND GOVERNMENT |
PUBLICATIONS | EVENTS | PODCASTS | NO LEFT TURNS BLOG | AUDIO ARCHIVE | DONATE | ABOUT US

 

Ashbrook Scholar Program:  Home | Apply Online | Request More Information | Course of Study | Faculty | Speakers |
Why Study History or Political Science? | Internship Opportunities | Student Publications | Financial Assistance | FAQ | Contact Us

Master of American History and Government:  Home | About | Admission | Schedule of Courses | Course Registration | Tuition | Faculty | Request More Information

TeachingAmericanHistory.org:  Home | Saturday Seminars | Summer Institutes | Partner on a Teaching American History Grant | Historical Documents Library | Audio Lectures and Discussions | Constitutional Convention | Ratification of the Constitution

Presidential Academy for American History and Civics:  Home | About the Program | Documents and Texts | Faculty | Itinerary | Application

Congressional Academy for American History and Civics:  Home | About the Program | Documents and Texts | Faculty | Itinerary | Application

Podcasts:  Home | What's a Podcast? | Subscribe

No Left Turns Blog  Home | Archive | Postings by Author | Comments by Our Readers | What's in a Name? | RSS Site Feed

Publications:  Home | Editorials | On Principle | Right from the Center | Dialogues | Books | Monographs |
Ashbrook Statesmanship Theses | Res Publica | Publication Request Form | Publications by Subject

Events:  Home | John M. Ashbrook Memorial Dinner | Major Issues Lecture Series | Colloquium |
Van Meter Scholarship Luncheon | Conferences and Special Events | Calendar of Events | On-Line Speeches (RealAudio)

About Us:  Home | Board of Advisors | Staff | Who Was John M. Ashbrook | Support the Ashbrook Center |
Map and Directions

 

Verizon Foundation
Support for ashbrook.org is provided by the Verizon Foundation.


John M. Ashbrook Center for Public Affairs
Ashland University
401 College Avenue | Ashland, Ohio 44805
(419) 289-5411  |   (877) 289-5411 (Toll Free)