Click Here to Go to the Ashbrook Center's Homepage

Subscribe to Our Email Update
 
SEARCH
 

Home



Support the Ashbrook Center



Subscribe to Our E-Mail Update




No Left Turns:
The Ashbrook
Center Blog







Ashbrook Scholar Program

Master of American History and Government






  Podcasts



Other Ashbrook
Web Sites:


AshbrookScholar.org



mahg.ashland.edu



TeachingAmerican
History.org


Document Library

Constitutional Convention

The American Founding



Presidential
Academy.org




Congressional
Academy.org




Letters from
an Ohio Farmer




VindicatingThe
Founders.com




ClassicsOf
Strategy.com

Respect Diversity:
The Electoral Vote is the Will of the People

Editorial
November 2000

by: Julie Ann Ponzi


The worst part about the political drama unfolding in Florida may be what the "experts" are saying about the Constitution. They tell us that the Electoral College is an outdated and outmoded form of calling presidential elections. They tell us that the only reason it was ever created was out of a fear of the stupidity of uniformed voters. As Hillary Clinton has put it in her calls for a Constitutional amendment to eliminate the Electoral College: "I’ve always thought we had outlived the need for an Electoral College, and now that I’m going to the Senate, I am going to try to do what I can to make clear that the popular vote, the will of the people, should be followed."

The men who wrote our Constitution had greater fears than voter stupidity--something that ironically distinguishes them from the Gore camp in Palm Beach. In fact, their fear was not so much stupidity of the American voter as of the wiles of overly ambitious politicians who might demagogue large segments of the population. Pretenders who might promise them bread and circuses in exchange for their votes might also subvert the rational and considered opinion of the country at large.

The Constitution is designed to stand as bedrock in times of great change and turmoil. It reflects a rational and considered opinion of the American people. If the rule of law prevails in our hearts and minds, we will respect it as the representation of our solemn will. Opinions change and fluctuate for all kinds of reasons and with great speed. But our respect fundamental opinion, the Constitution, should stand and guide us through these tempests.

The Founders knew that a nation is composed of more than individual citizens. We are not now and never were intended to be a simple democracy. Such systems may work when there is a small homogeneous community in question but even in the time of the Founders our country was thought to be too diverse for such a simplistic plan. There are competing interests, geographical and regional differences, and in the case of rural versus city life, completely different approaches to day-to-day life. A President, when representing that nation, must reflect all of this--not just a segment of it. If he owes his election only to a popular vote energized and fueled by one set of interests, citizens not part of that segment cannot feel secure that their interests or rights will be protected.

Remember that the Founders drafted our Constitution but they did not legitimize it. It had to be ratified by the American people and, to the extent that we do not object through the channels therein provided, we are bound by it. If we choose to change it we may do so but an unconsidered opinion on changing our Constitution is as dangerous as a conscious disregard of the law. If we are going to have a debate about such monumental questions as the usefulness of the Electoral College, let us have it apart from the heated discussions that pre-occupy the nation at this time.

The irony not seen by those opposed to the Electoral College is that it is meant to secure a voice for the otherwise oppressed. It is meant to protect the rights of the minority in a national election. But above all, it is part of our Constitution and, as such, it is the solemn will of the American people. A refusal to acknowledge that is a willingness to cast a blind eye upon the tyranny that comes when the rule of law is ignored. But in the age of Clinton, should that really surprise us?

Julie Ann Ponzi is an adjunct fellow of the Ashbrook Center and former professor of American Politics. She is now a stay-at-home mother.



 


Printer-Friendly Version

Upcoming Events

Mike Huckabee
Thursday, June 28

Maureen O’Connor on the Constitution
Monday, Sept. 17


Recent Publications


A Policy Analysis of Local New York Laws Banning Oil and Gas Exploration by Robert Alt

Obamacare and the Supreme Court: An Opportunity for Reflection by Michael Schwarz

Moratoria on Drilling are Legally Dubious by Robert Alt

Rick Santorum and Limited Government by Andrew E. Busch

Who Owns the Bard? by Ellen Tucker

Clarence Thomas and the Wisdom of the Founding by Ken Masugi

U.S. Headed in the Right Direction by Peter W. Schramm

Deficits and Cultural Politics by David Marion

America’s Future in New Europe by Justin Paulette

Our Discussion of Islam by David Foster

The Tea Party and Nullification by Michael Sabo

Drama Queens: Elizabeth Taylor, Camille Paglia, and the Purposes of Female Power by Julie Ponzi

Honoring Ronald Reagan by Peter W. Schramm

Realigning American Politics: Do We Still Hold These Truths? by Matthew Spalding

Reagan’s Inherent Goodness Made Him One of the Great Presidents by Peter W. Schramm

Reagan the Radical by Stephen Knott


Audio Archive


Terrence Moore on Education Reform (2012)

Stephen Moore on Capitalism (2012)

David Tucker on Fear and Freedom (2012)

Reed Browning on the War of Austrian Succession (2012)

Pat Tiberi on the American Dream (2012)

Ramesh Ponnuru on Obamanomics (2011)

Gordon Lloyd on Political Economy (2011)

Steven Hayward on the Health of Capitalism in America (2011)

John Boehner (2011)

Jonah Goldberg on Liberalism (2010)

Mitt Romney (2010)

John Kasich on the Future of Ohio (2009)

Conference on the Presidency and the Courts featuring President George W. Bush (2008)

Jeb Bush on America’s Promise (2008)

Glenn Beck on Militant Islam (2006)

Karl Rove on Conservatism (2005)

James McPherson on the Battle of Antietam (2005)

David Hackett Fischer on Liberty and Freedom (2004)

William Bennett on the Politics of War (2004)

Edwin Meese on Homeland Security (2003)

Barbara Bush on CSPAN (2003)

Victor Davis Hanson on Terrorism (2003)

Benjamin Netanyahu on Attaining Peace (2002)

Clarence Thomas on the Supreme Court (1999)

Margaret Thatcher on Ronald Reagan and Freedom (1993)

Dick Cheney on American Foreign Policy (1991)

Ronald Reagan on John Ashbrook (1983)

  Real Logo
Visit our archive of over 200 other Ashbrook speeches at
audio.ashbrook.org or subscribe to our
Events Podcast.








ASHBROOK SCHOLAR PROGRAM | MASTER OF AMERICAN HISTORY AND GOVERNMENT |
PUBLICATIONS | EVENTS | PODCASTS | NO LEFT TURNS BLOG | AUDIO ARCHIVE | DONATE | ABOUT US

 

Ashbrook Scholar Program:  Home | Apply Online | Request More Information | Course of Study | Faculty | Speakers |
Why Study History or Political Science? | Internship Opportunities | Student Publications | Financial Assistance | FAQ | Contact Us

Master of American History and Government:  Home | About | Admission | Schedule of Courses | Course Registration | Tuition | Faculty | Request More Information

TeachingAmericanHistory.org:  Home | Saturday Seminars | Summer Institutes | Partner on a Teaching American History Grant | Historical Documents Library | Audio Lectures and Discussions | Constitutional Convention | Ratification of the Constitution

Presidential Academy for American History and Civics:  Home | About the Program | Documents and Texts | Faculty | Itinerary | Application

Congressional Academy for American History and Civics:  Home | About the Program | Documents and Texts | Faculty | Itinerary | Application

Podcasts:  Home | What's a Podcast? | Subscribe

No Left Turns Blog  Home | Archive | Postings by Author | Comments by Our Readers | What's in a Name? | RSS Site Feed

Publications:  Home | Editorials | On Principle | Right from the Center | Dialogues | Books | Monographs |
Ashbrook Statesmanship Theses | Res Publica | Publication Request Form | Publications by Subject

Events:  Home | John M. Ashbrook Memorial Dinner | Major Issues Lecture Series | Colloquium |
Van Meter Scholarship Luncheon | Conferences and Special Events | Calendar of Events | On-Line Speeches (RealAudio)

About Us:  Home | Board of Advisors | Staff | Who Was John M. Ashbrook | Support the Ashbrook Center |
Map and Directions

 

Verizon Foundation
Support for ashbrook.org is provided by the Verizon Foundation.


John M. Ashbrook Center for Public Affairs
Ashland University
401 College Avenue | Ashland, Ohio 44805
(419) 289-5411  |   (877) 289-5411 (Toll Free)